The Cursed Legacy of Brazil's Workers' Party
by Bolivar Lamounier
Feb. 27, 2017.
The age of Lula as the head of the Workers' Party (PT) wounded Brazil's democracy much more deeply than it has generally been acknowledged. Some aspects of this sad legacy are in plain view: The systemic corruption, the radioactivity of which is still going strong with no end in sight; the economic madness of Dilma's administration, which raised the number of the unemployed to more than twelve million.
However, one of the worst screw-ups--the consequences of which will last for a long time--consisted in the sullying of the language of the public life.
I'm referring here to not just the systematic cult of the lie and the ideological falsification of history, but also to the political use of conceptual aberrations, which were often endorsed by the party's self appointed intellectuals. The best example of this kind of fraud lies in the vision of a society divided between "us" (the people, the good guys, Good) and "them" (the elites, the bad guys, the greedy).
Since its inception 36 years ago the cornerstone of this discourse rests on the notion of elite. Not an aristocratic elite, the result of a hereditary nobility, which Brazil clearly lacks. What Brazil does have is an aggregate of those holding the highest posts in the different hierarchies: the electable politicians, the creme de la creme of the civil and military bureaucracies, the most important businessmen; the top echelons of the intellectual and scientific communities, and so forth--a very abstract grouping of merely statistical value. Understood as a grouping of thousands of individuals, it is clear that this "elite" is incapable of conspiring, a realization that leads us to the irony of ironies: The best example of a country governed by a conspiratorial elite was presented by the Workers' Party itself. When Lula & Co. viscerally partnered up with the contractors' cartel, it conspired all it could--all done in a very professional way. If in the end they were caught, the explanation is twofold: 1) the size of the animal they sought to devour: Petrobras, and 2) the humongous size of their arrogance and its accompanying sense of impunity.
(http://istoe.com.br/heranca-maldita-do-pt/)
Translated from the Portuguese by yours truly.
by Bolivar Lamounier
Feb. 27, 2017.
The age of Lula as the head of the Workers' Party (PT) wounded Brazil's democracy much more deeply than it has generally been acknowledged. Some aspects of this sad legacy are in plain view: The systemic corruption, the radioactivity of which is still going strong with no end in sight; the economic madness of Dilma's administration, which raised the number of the unemployed to more than twelve million.
However, one of the worst screw-ups--the consequences of which will last for a long time--consisted in the sullying of the language of the public life.
I'm referring here to not just the systematic cult of the lie and the ideological falsification of history, but also to the political use of conceptual aberrations, which were often endorsed by the party's self appointed intellectuals. The best example of this kind of fraud lies in the vision of a society divided between "us" (the people, the good guys, Good) and "them" (the elites, the bad guys, the greedy).
Since its inception 36 years ago the cornerstone of this discourse rests on the notion of elite. Not an aristocratic elite, the result of a hereditary nobility, which Brazil clearly lacks. What Brazil does have is an aggregate of those holding the highest posts in the different hierarchies: the electable politicians, the creme de la creme of the civil and military bureaucracies, the most important businessmen; the top echelons of the intellectual and scientific communities, and so forth--a very abstract grouping of merely statistical value. Understood as a grouping of thousands of individuals, it is clear that this "elite" is incapable of conspiring, a realization that leads us to the irony of ironies: The best example of a country governed by a conspiratorial elite was presented by the Workers' Party itself. When Lula & Co. viscerally partnered up with the contractors' cartel, it conspired all it could--all done in a very professional way. If in the end they were caught, the explanation is twofold: 1) the size of the animal they sought to devour: Petrobras, and 2) the humongous size of their arrogance and its accompanying sense of impunity.
(http://istoe.com.br/heranca-maldita-do-pt/)
Translated from the Portuguese by yours truly.
