Saturday, June 10, 2006

What they're saying about Brazil and Brazilians II

dispatches
Inside Brazil's Landless Movement
What to the shantytown residents do all day?
By David Morton
Updated Friday, June 9, 2006, at 5:35 AM ET



From: David Morton
Subject: A Do-It-Yourself Paradise for the People
Posted Wednesday, June 7, 2006, at 11:45 AM ET
Children's Day, a national holiday in Brazil, is like Christmas in October. Even at the remote southern edge of the Amazon rainforest, in a shantytown of the landless poor, they don't stint on the celebrations. Women from the encampment engineered a giant, 7-foot-long cake, baked in pieces in wood furnaces or propane stoves. The DJ powered up the donated stereo system with a car battery and cued up the forró. Another guy coated his face in red lipstick, transforming himself into a clown, the main event. Although not every kid got toys, the clown made sure none lacked a bag of candy, though they sometimes had to wrestle him to the ground to get at it. Dancing fizzled out when the car battery died. Some girls insisted on playing musical chairs without music, deciding that clapping worked fine.
About 400 families live in the wooden shanties of the Claudinei de Barros encampment, a dozen acres of muck on the outskirts of the city of Sinop. At the shantytown's borders are sawmills, a slaughterhouse, and a soy plantation. A generation ago, everything in sight was rainforest. Today, the red banner of the Brazilian landless movement's largest organization—known as the Movimento dos Trabalhadores Rurais Sem Terra, or the MST—flies above a sort of do-it-yourself paradise for the people. "Here, you don't have to pay for water, for electricity, for rent," the encampment's 26-year-old coordinator, Edilson Silva, told me. He expounded on the dignity conferred on those who swapped a squalid life in the city for a dirt-floor shack and the key to a communal outhouse. Water comes from any number of wells, and there's a milky lake out back for washing clothes. They don't pay for power, because, apart from car batteries, there isn't any. And they don't pay rent because the land, the footprint of a long-gone sawmill, has fallen into the possession of a bank. The movement occupies it illegally.

The goal of the MST is to force the federal government to speed up land redistribution. Theoretically, the group has the constitution on its side. Much of the privately held farmland in Brazil lies fallow. The government can expropriate this idle land (negotiating a purchase price with the owner) and then settle poor farmers on the property. In practice, though, there's not much budgeted for the program. What's more, landowners have little trouble tying up the process in the courts. So, guided by the spirit of the legislation, the movement's strategy is to break the law. Several hundred families will leave their shacks at the crack of dawn, show up on private land waving hoes and machetes, and start building shelters with whatever wood and plastic sheeting they can carry.
The pressure tactics have produced results. The MST has moved more than 300,000 Brazilian families from temporary quarters like the one in Sinop to permanent farm settlements. But the confrontations have levied a heavy toll. Police and landowners have killed more than 1,200 landless activists since the movement began in the mid-1980s, according to the Pastoral Land Commission, a group affiliated with the Roman Catholic Church.

The Children's Day festivities happened to fall exactly two years after the movement's first occupation in the area. In 2003, Edilson and other MST organizers launched a recruitment drive in the slums of the cities of northern Mato Grosso, the state where Sinop is located, and staged the invasion of an abandoned farm. The occupation lasted only 30 days before police evicted them from the site. If its anniversary passed unnoticed, even by Edilson, it was probably because there hadn't been many successes worth remembering. Three years had passed since the MST had formed a permanent settlement anywhere in the state.

I spent a week at the Sinop encampment last October. The owner of my one-room shack was in the state capital. The movement had occupied the area around the land-reform agency there, and activists from Mato Grosso took turns living in shacks on the sidewalk for 60 days at a time. My closest neighbor in Sinop was Valdir Oliveira, a 40-year-old handyman who had built an elaborate two-story shack for his wife and four children, complete with a chicken coop, a living room, and a urinal that saved on perilous nighttime trips to the outhouse. Four months before, he had left his house because work was spotty and he could no longer pay the rent. His 19-year-old son and 18-year-old daughter were now the family's chief wage-earners—he in a Sinop clothing store, she at a sandwich counter—jobs that paid about $5 a day. They would soon leave their jobs to fulfill their two-month obligation in the capital. "We have to let them know we exist," Valdir said of his new turn as a revolutionary. "You have to wake them up. If not, nothing's going to happen."
The encampment would go silent at 10 p.m. when "quiet hours" went into effect, and every night you would hear the squeals of a dying dog chained outside the shack. I was told that, like many pets in the encampment, he had probably been poisoned by the lake water. You would also hear the rumble of trucks on the highway, those going south loaded with Amazon timber, those going north headed for another load. The military regime had opened the rainforest to development in the 1970s, and hundreds of thousands of people from Brazil's south and northeast came to Mato Grosso to stake out plots of land to farm. They discovered that, while land was plentiful, virtually none of it was theirs to settle. With the aid of faked title deeds, some corrupt local officials, private armies, and wealthy farmers claimed huge swaths, much of it federal property. They then cleared it flat, carpeting the earth with soy. The state became a Texas-sized environmental crime scene.

Agriculture has been steadily booming since, illicit logging runs rampant, and 2003-04 was the worst year of Amazon devastation in the last decade. The government says that most of the timber is logged illegally on fraudulent licenses. Some of it is exported, and a good share of the exports end up in the United States. The shacks of the encampment were built from the scraps.



From: David Morton
Subject: The Activists Pack Up Their Hoes and Stage an Occupation
Posted Thursday, June 8, 2006, at 10:48 AM ET
Given its dependence on natural light, the encampment generally wakes with the sunrise. But on the morning of Oct. 1, coffee was brewing on wood-fueled stovetops at 3:30 a.m. The night before, organizers had readied families for a predawn occupation. The target was a state legislator's plantation a few miles up the highway. As always, participation was mandatory. Families collected their farming tools and sacks of beans and rice, marched to the site, cut through the wire fence, and by 5:30 a.m. several hundred landless activists were hard at work chopping down the politician's eucalyptus trees.
The action was symbolic. The fazendeiro was one of the largest landowners in the area, and the eucalyptus he had planted were cultivated for export. Within minutes of the invasion, the plantation manager appeared and pleaded with the intruders to stop destroying the crop. When were they going to leave? They would leave once they had harvested their beans and rice, replied Edilson Silva, the group's coordinator, who then returned to hoeing a furrow in the earth.

When a couple of dozen police officers arrived at the scene, everyone stopped their work and, hoes and machetes in hand, they formed a human blockade along the length of the broken fence. The standard negotiation was about to begin. "Let us in, or we'll cut your throat," the officer in charge said.

Edilson had little reason to back down. Murder at the hands of the police wasn't probable, at least in this part of the state. And allowing them through the barricade would more likely lead to roundups than productive talks. A roundup would be disastrous. Chances were they'd be trucked to their home cities, as many as a couple of hundred miles away, rather than back to the encampment. A dispersal like that could destroy the movement.
Other than numbers, the activists on the barricade had the advantage of time. Previous confrontations and the ensuing legal battles that followed had convinced the local police force to grudgingly respect the 48-hour waiting period occupiers were guaranteed before a forced removal. Sure enough, the lead officer softened his threatening tone after radioing his commander. The invaders marched home later that day.

Most of the movement's occupations around Sinop have been just as brief, and the results have been just as intangible. Hundreds of MST activists blockaded the highway once, halting all timber traffic from the Amazon. That lasted for an afternoon. Another time, police officers broke up an occupation at Sinop's city hall with tear gas after a few days, long before any meaningful concessions could be negotiated. In one notable setback, a fazendeiro lured eight MST members away from the movement during a short occupation of his plantation. He hired them on to his private security force.

In May, at an encampment about 60 miles east of Sinop, men allegedly hired by local landowners abducted seven landless activists, an eighth was severely beaten, and a ninth stabbed. It's a miracle no one's been killed yet. When the movement arrived in this part of Mato Grosso two years ago, there were rumors of a $900-per-head bounty for killing activists. As it is, murder in Brazil doesn't require much provocation. When people from the MST start waving their machetes—more an expression of peasant power than practical weaponry—fazendeiros reply with gun-toting goon squads. "The people are the weapon," says Edilson, but it's still a lopsided contest. Landowners aren't getting killed, activists are. Massacres are relatively common, including the killing of 19 at an encampment in the eastern Amazon in 1996, perhaps the movement's defining moment. Countless MST settlements and temporary shantytowns end up named for people martyred during the struggle. In 2005, a camp about 50 miles north was named in honor of Dorothy Stang, a 73-year-old missionary from Dayton, Ohio. Stang, who belonged to a landless organization frequently allied with the MST, had complained about loggers illegally raiding the area of the eastern Amazon where she was helping form an environmentally sustainable settlement. Last February, one of those loggers had her gunned down.

Edilson lives in a two-room shack at the edge of the encampment with his wife, his sister, and his infant son. When we spoke, he spread his personal library on the table of his open-air kitchen. The works were what you might expect: Lenin, Mao, and, naturally, Che, the MST's patron saint. Edilson raged that it seemed someone always had to die before progress could be made, before headlines pressured a judge to rule on a case or for the government to finally purchase land for settlement. And then, with a gesture to his books, he grew more philosophical about the sacrifice. "In all the great conquests, people are killed."

The shantytown doesn't have a true leader. Officially, it's run by a governing council of elected representatives. Edilson is the chief strategist and ideological spark plug, and on Sundays he is the star striker on the MST soccer team as it takes on squads from the sawmills on the small pitch by the highway. As a teenager, he worked as the houseboy and bagman for a wealthy landowner and drug trafficker, before his stepfather yanked him back home. He joined the movement at 19, when his mother got her own plot of land in an MST-organized settlement downstate. He passed through a phase of evangelical fanaticism before abandoning the church and entering the movement's training program for militants. Israel, a slightly older stepbrother, chose a different path. He was a gunman in a landowner's security force. His job was to "clean the land"—that is, steal it from small farmers. Israel died at 17, shot dead by 14 bullets.
Most of the encampment's residents crave rest after lifetimes of desperate migration around Brazil. Edilson, though, acknowledges other aims. "I have a task in the movement, and this is bigger than my dream of having a piece of land. Some people want to die on their own land. But I'm the opposite. I want to die fighting." His wife isn't too happy about that.



From: David Morton
Subject: What Do the Shantytown Residents Do All Day?
Posted Friday, June 9, 2006, at 5:35 AM ET
A 24-hour guard post divides the landless movement's encampment from another shantytown closer to the highway. At first glance, the squalor on the other side of the fence doesn't seem so different. But some residents of the encampment look down their noses at their neighbors. It's a village of "homeless people," they told me. The homeless aren't fighting for anything, and they have no discipline and no future, they said; at best, they're merely surviving. "They have lots of guns. It's like a favela."
The landless activists may be fighting for some higher purpose while their neighbors in the so-called favela are just ticking off the days to oblivion. But they're waiting all the same. On that score, there have been some positive developments. The government land-reform agency appears close to acquiring some nearby private farms for redistribution to the MST. Families who've been in the movement the longest—two years—will get first priority.

Nothing is certain, and in the meantime, there's a lot of daylight to kill. The thrilling land invasions and demonstrations are relatively rare, and few in the encampment have regular work to occupy their time. A few more residents are unemployed now that the federal police have cracked down on a fraudulent logging-license ring. Dozens were arrested for the scheme, including top officials at the state's environmental-protection office. With more monitoring than usual, the timber supply has tightened, and local sawmills have reduced their workforces. (Not that the sawmills employed that many people to begin with. They're like cemeteries, one movement militant told me, "Lots of dead trees and one person looking after the mill.")

The hard-core movement types tend to crowd their schedules with committee work. Someone has to organize the nighttime security patrol, get the trash holes dug, teach the literacy classes, hold the disciplinary hearings for the people who skipped their assigned work shifts. One woman already had her hands full helping run the disciplinary committee and the encampment's pharmacy, but when she was laid off by the nearby sawmill, she felt the anxiety of inactivity. She took to carrying around a stethoscope and cuff and randomly checking people's blood pressure.

There are regular fishing expeditions to the nearby Teles-Pides River, a branch of the Amazon, where a sort of satellite camp sits on unused private land that was once cleared for soy. "House of Friends" reads a sign nailed to the shack. "Preserve nature. It needs us and we need it." The anglers there told me the fishing had gone bad because of the toxins from the soy crop dusters. Near the shelter, workers were building a bridge that will extend the paved road further into the rainforest.
The encampment also has its share of opportunists—single men who show up at the gate because they hear there's a plot of land in it for them. They move their few belongings into a barren shack and then disappear after a few months, tired of holding out for a payoff that might never come. One afternoon, I found myself with a group of malcontents who had gathered in a shack taking slugs from plastic bottles of pinga and complaining about the encampment's rules. You're always having to attend meetings for this or that, they whined, and if you miss a few, you're liable to get kicked out of the movement. A few hours later, one of the men was wandering drunk around the encampment wearing a dress and with the word "Amor" scrawled on his forehead in red lipstick.

In early 2005, when the encampment was located farther up the highway, there was something of an insurrection. A group of about 20 people announced that the movement wasn't getting them anywhere. They burned the MST flag, stalked around armed with guns, and opened merger talks with another landless organization. At a general meeting that was called to resolve the situation, one of the gunmen fired into the air, scattering everyone to their shacks. The residents of the encampment were packing up for the new location anyway. With the move to a new patch of dirt, the putschists were left behind. They later requested re-admittance and were refused.

Plenty of the people I spoke to said they were willing to stick it out forever, no matter how long it took to get farmland of their own. But others were more restless. My neighbor in the encampment, Valdir Oliveira, had thought it through. This is an election year, and President Lula, theoretically an MST ally, isn't likely to do anything to upset landowner interests. So, 2006 is a wash. If Lula wins again, Valdir will expand his two-story shack and give the president 2007 to get his rocky administration in order. If Valdir's prospects for settlement still didn't look good by then, he'll move on.

Valdir's friend Vilson had more difficulty adjusting to the idea of an extended stay. He was in his late 30s or early 40s (he wouldn't say exactly how old he was), the last surviving brother of five. He had spent five years as a prospector during the Amazon gold rush of the '80s and had done seven months in prison for something he wouldn't disclose. But he was no longer a desperado. His current wife (his 10th) was pregnant, and he wanted to slow down. He was all for the movement, although at one meeting I saw that after two months he still hadn't mastered the words to the MST anthem. A major storm hit during my week in the encampment, and the roof of Vilson's shack blew off. The following day he had to borrow a bicycle and cash and travel 15 miles to get more roofing material. When he returned, he seemed crestfallen. Life in the mud was wearing him down.
"We live under plastic roofs," he said. "We cook under here. It gets real hot. It's not healthy. When it rains, the floors become puddles. This is suffering."

He said he'd give it six more months. He's still there, eight months later.

David Morton is a freelance writer based in Washington, D.C. He has also contributed to the New Republic, Foreign Policy, and Newsday. You can e-mail him at davidsmorton1975@gmail.com.

Article URL: http://www.slate.com/id/2143129/

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

Deixe aqui sua opinião!

<< Home