Thursday, June 15, 2006

ABOUT WAL-MART

This well-documented article was published at http://www.onwardoregon.org

WAL-MART Background Overview

Wal-Mart has adversely affected every community in which it is located. It is now apparent that Wal-Mart's toll on rural communities is worse than on urban ones. Many of our fellow citizens wish they had been forewarned. Fortunately, there is now abundant documentation of the 'Wal-Mart effects.' They appear below. (Since municipal planning bodies often use traffic and public safety criteria to decide on Wal-Mart, we recommend you emphasize these points should you choose to compose your own letter. Even though fiscal and economic considerations are often not included in the 'criteria' we believe they probably do affect this somewhat subjective decision-making process.) A recurrent thread is Wal-Mart's exploitation of local, regional and state resources (i.e., your tax dollars) to make its record profits.

5,000 – 8,000 additional car trips/day causing congestion, increased commute times, and increased public safety risks.
Destruction of local business communities due to predatory business practices.
Increased crime, particularly parking lot crime.
Increased municipal expenditures for police and public safety services (expenditures that far exceed tax receipts from the store).
Increased property taxes to support city budgets.
Replacement of existing higher paying retail jobs with lower paying ones and, after elimination of local businesses, a decrease in the region's employment.
Failure to pay fair wage and benefits—a documented company policy.
Shrinking of the regional economy (failure to use local manufacturers; employees too underpaid to shop elsewhere in town; profits wired daily to Wal-Mart bank in Bentonville, Arkansas.)
Worsening of poverty in the region (failure to pay fair wage and benefits, elimination of competitors, removal of money from local economy).
Increased expenditures at state and local level to support Wal-Mart employees receiving public assistance.
Decreased commercial property values due to excess vacancy caused by Wal-Mart's destruction of local business community.
Decreased residential property values due to increased traffic and noise; worsening of air and water quality; and increased crime.
Repeated violations of Clean Water Act. Parking lot, auto and garden chemical (including herbicide and pesticide) run-off into surrounding areas, including local creeks, rivers and lakes.
Near term abandonment of property
Read on for more information or act now >>
Wal-Mart traffic places an intolerable burden on rural roads and congested urban areas.

Traffic is the issue upon which local planning officials find it easiest to vote down a Wal-Mart proposal. Typical Wal-Marts draw an additional 5,000 – 8,000 car trips/day. Wal-Mart development proposals often provide a specific estimate of expected car traffic for each site. Narrow and awkwardly constructed small town roads are ill-equipped to handle this type of traffic and most urban regions are already congested. Residential areas surrounding the development are most adversely affected by the increased congestion, traffic and noise and worsening air and water quality (see below) and parking lot crime. When evaluating traffic movement into a proposed Wal-Mart area, consider nearby intersections and where the detour and turn around traffic would route itself. Are there schools, parks and emergency services that will be adversely affected? Are there bus stops, school crossings or other existing pedestrian traffic? How does commuter traffic flow through the area? How will shoppers enter and leave the parking lot? How does the state currently rate the safety of adjacent roads and nearby intersections? Does a nearby accident-prone area already exist? Most citizen groups hire an independent traffic engineer to help them evaluate the site and to more objectively critique Wal-Mart's traffic analysis and mitigation proposals. Other Wal-Mart towns have experienced decreased residential property values due solely to the adverse impact of high volume shopper traffic. Read on for more information or act now >>

Wal-Mart replaces higher wage jobs with lower wage jobs, requires taxpayer assistance to keep Wal-Mart employees afloat and worsens the region's poverty.

When Wal-Mart targets a new community, it typically boasts about the number of new jobs that will be created—usually 200 to 400. Numerous studies reveal that, contrary to the company's PR, Wal-Mart does not create new jobs; it simply replaces higher paying retail jobs with lower paying ones and, due to its adverse impact upon local businesses, may actually cause a net decrease in job numbers. (1) Rural areas are particularly apt to suffer: up to 47% of local retailers will be put out of business by Wal-Mart. (2)

On its website, (walmartfacts.com), Wal-Mart states that, in Oregon, the average associate makes $10.09/hour. This is misleading; the 'average' is inflated by failing to distinguish between management and non-management wages, between the higher grocery wages and non-grocery wages and between full- and part-time wages. One-third of Wal-Mart employees are officially part-time and deliberately underemployed to save Wal-Mart from paying for benefits. (3) This fraction is expected to increase as Wal-Mart has recently made plans to under-employ even more employees to decrease its health insurance costs. (4) A 2004 report from the US House of Representatives Committee on Education and the Workforce estimated the average Wal-Mart non-grocery wage (which the company refuses to disclose) as $7.50 to $8.50/hr, well below the average retail wage of $12.17.(5) The House report concluded that the wages of Wal-Mart employees fall well below poverty standards, even with a full-time work week (considered by Wal-Mart to be 34 hours/week). Also contrary to what Wal-Mart says, only 41 to 46 percent of its associates receive health benefits, compared to 66 percent at similar large firms. A 2003 AFL-CIO report concluded that Wal-Mart health care coverage was essentially unaffordable to Wal-Mart families due to monthly premiums, deductibles and a one-third co-pay for all services. (6) (7) While Wal-Mart discourages its employees from using the company health plan, it does encourage them to apply for public assistance, effectively shifting labor costs to the taxpayer. A 2004 University of California study revealed that, even compared to other large retailers, Wal-Mart poses an especially heavy burden on tax payers: Their workers earn 31 percent less and require 39% more in public assistance. (8) Read on for more information or act now >>

A growing number of states, including Washington, list Wal-Mart as the number one beneficiary or among the top corporate beneficiaries of its tax-payer-supported health assistance programs. (9) Oregon either does not track this data or does not make it readily available. In California (and other states), Wal-Mart was found to be instructing employees on application procedures for Medicaid, food stamps and temporary assistance to needy families. This enraged California Assemblywoman Sally Lieber who stated that California could not afford to "keep large, wealthy corporations on the dole." (10) A 2004 Penn State University study found that it was more difficult for counties with Wal-Marts to raise their residents out of poverty than for counties without Wal-Marts.(11) Allowing Wal-Mart to shift costs onto taxpayers not only hides the true cost of the retailer's discount program, but places more responsible businesses at a competitive disadvantage. Read on for more information or act now >>


Wal-Mart guts local retail communities and historic districts turning them into 'ghost towns.'

Wal-Mart's size and dominance of the retail market result in competitive advantages unable to be matched by local businesses. Studies show that rural communities are especially hard hit with up to 47% of retailers going out of business. (12) Even large chains like Kmart, Walgreen, Target, Fred Meyer, Toys 'R' Us and big grocery retailers lose market share to Wal-Mart.(13) A 1996 Iowa State University study of seven Iowa communities with Wal-Mart stores found that eighty-four percent of all sales at the new Wal-Marts came at the expense of existing businesses within the same county. Many of these businesses eventually failed including automotive stores, hardware stores, grocery stores, drug stores, apparel stores, and sporting goods stores. Historic districts and town centers were deserted. (14) This Wal-Mart effect has been widely documented. (15) (16) (17)(18) Read on for more information or act now >>

In fact, eliminating the local competition is a calculated part of Wal-Mart's business model and reveals the mean-spiritedness behind Wal-Mart's community-friendly face. Testimony by former Wal-Mart managers document that Wal-Mart's rock bottom loss leader prices (on items such as cd's, toys, diapers, motor oil and laundry detergent) are set by store managers who vigilantly survey the local competition and intentionally under-price items to lure customers away from their regular shopping spots. (19) When the competition goes belly up, Wal-Mart's prices rebound, often to levels higher than that offered by the out-of-business competitor. Read on for more information or act now >>


Wal-Mart costs local taxpayers between $70,200 and $93,600 annually.

A 2002 fiscal analysis of the retail community in Barnstable, Massachusetts found that big box stores drain revenue from city coffers at the rate of $ 468 /1000 sq ft. Other studies concur: the costs of servicing Big Box Retailers outpace the tax revenue they produce. Municipalities pick up the tab for additional road maintenance and public safety services (parking lot accidents) and police services (bad checks, shoplifting, parking lot crime). (21) At a size of 150,000 – 200,000 sq ft, Wal-Mart costs municipalities between $70,200 and $93,600 annually. In contrast, the Barnstable study found that small, specialty retail stores actually generate revenue for municipalities at the rate of $326 per 1,000 square feet. At a total comparable square footage of between 150,000 and 200,000 sq ft, that would be an annual municipal revenue gain of between $48,900 and $65,200. (22) (23) Read on for more information or act now >>


Wal-Mart erodes the local tax base and requires property tax increases.

Because local businesses bring in more tax revenue than do big boxes like Wal-Mart, their elimination creates problems for city and county budgets. This was expertly documented in a 2001 economic analysis for the city of Concord NH, (24). During the 1990's, Concord added 2.8 million square feet of new commercial development (primarily 'big box' retailers) but tax revenue declined by 19 percent. The shrinking tax base was attributed to the death of local businesses, and to a decline in residential property values caused by increased traffic and noise. Concord had to raise its property taxes—now one of the highest rates in the state—to make up for the lost revenue. This phenomenon has been documented in other towns across the US. (25) Read on for more information or act now >>


Wal-mart shrinks regional economies.

A 2003 economic impact analysis of an area in midcoast Maine, found that local businesses returned 44.6% of their revenues to the local economy while big boxes returned only 14.1%, mostly in the form of payroll. (26). A 2003 economic analysis of a Chicago suburb, found that big box stores generate $105/sq ft for the local economy compared to $179/sq ft generated by local businesses. (27) Wal-Mart stores at a size of 150,000 to 200,000 sq feet, return $11 to 15 million less annually to the local economy than would several local businesses with comparable total square footage. And since Wal-Mart will shut down these local businesses, the economy will experience a net subtraction of money. There are three additional reasons that Wal-Mart stores shrink regional economies. First, Wal-Mart does not use local suppliers and distributors; it imports almost all of its products from overseas. Second, Wal-Mart associates receive poverty-level wages; one of the few places they can shop is Wal-Mart, thus recycling their wages back to the company instead of local retailers. Third, Wal-Mart's profits are wired on a daily basis to its own Bank of Bentonville, Bentonville, Arkansas, owned by Jim C.Walton, son of Sam Walton, company founder. The profits do not get invested here in Oregon. Read on for more information or act now >>


Wal-Mart has been sued repeatedly for Clean Water Act violations.

Parking lot run-off increases the risk of flooding and pollution of nearby neighborhoods as well as the watershed. Wal-Marts are often slated to be built in open fields and in many cases adjacent to environmentally sensitive areas. Parking lot run-off increases the risk of flooding and contributes new sources of water pollution to the community. According to the US EPA, runoff from streets, parking lots, and rooftops, called non-point pollution, now ranks as the top source of water pollution in the US, ahead of industrial discharges. (28) New retail centers deliver the largest and most polluted volumes of run-off, primarily due to their large parking lots and destruction of pervious (water-absorbing) landscape. (29) The total runoff for a one-acre parking lot is 16 times that of a one-acre meadow. (30). Independent experts have also shown that this degree of run-off cannot be mitigated by storm drainage systems, no matter how elaborate. (31) Read on for more information or act now >>

Run-off from the parking lot, auto areas and storage of lawn and garden chemicals in the parking lot will cause heavy metals, industrial chemicals including petroleum, motor oil, and other hydrocarbons, and fertilizers, pesticides and other 'garden' chemicals to run off into surrounding neighborhoods, the street and into the watershed. Large bags of garden chemicals, including pesticides and herbicides, are stored in the parking lot. As the bags are moved and handled, they open and freely leak their contents. The wear from car tires and break pads contributes copper, cadmium and zinc from the parking areas. (32) Wal-Mart has been sued repeatedly in numerous states for violations of the Federal Clean Water Act. (33) Apparently, it is cheaper for the company to litigate on a case-by-case basis than to clean up its act. The Connecticut Attorney General described the violations in his state, resulting in pesticides, fertilizers, and other pollutants entering waterways and causing a "serious threat to water quality and public health," as "irresponsible and reprehensible." (34) Read on for more information or act now >>


Wal-Mart monopolizes the time and energy of municipal public safety officials. And costs the taxpayers.

Numerous reports and lawsuits document that Wal-Mart takes inadequate measures to police its own premises and, in its continuing effort to cut costs, shifts this burden to municipal public safety officials. Numerous communities report increased police response time, decreased neighborhood presence, decreased numbers of traffic tickets issued (because the police were tied up at Wal-Mart), and increased public safety costs after Wal-Mart's arrival. Parking lot crime has been particularly troublesome for Wal-Mart. When selling a new store, company officials typically understate the Wal-Mart crime effect to local officials who are ill-prepared to deal with the subsequent crime spike and blow to police budget.(35) Read on for more information or act now >>


Wal-Mart does not utilize local or regional suppliers.

Wal-Mart states it brings increased business to local and regional manufacturers. However, Wal-Mart's investment in local manufacturing has declined dramatically over the last decade. The company is now the number one importer of Chinese goods. In fact, Wal-Mart commands such a large percentage of its suppliers markets that it can hold suppliers hostage to stringent cost cutting demands. Business Week reports that Wal-Mart controls "a large and rapidly increasing share of the business done by most every major U.S. consumer-products company: 28% of Dial total sales, 24% of Del Monte Food's, 23% of Clorox's, 23% of Revlon's, and on down the list." (36) Most American manufacturers are not able to supply Wal-Mart at heavily discounted prices and, consequently, are forced to merge, go overseas or go out of business. This was the fate of Wal-Mart suppliers Rubbermaid, Fruit of the Loom, Levi Strauss and Master Lock. Wal-Mart was once a solid account for Rob Reed's company, Stitches, a small sewing contractor that ultimately failed. "But every season, Reed said, the retailer demanded a lower price, shrinking his profit to the point that an unexpected expense could push him into the red." (37) As the number one importer of Chinese goods, Wal-Mart is not interested in expanding its manufacturing base in Oregon. Read on for more information or act now >>


Wal-Mart's Presence Devalues Property.

The Supercenter will have multiple adverse effects on nearby neighborhoods. These range from noise pollution; light pollution; flooding due to increased run-off; increased traffic congestion, gridlock and aggressive driving; decreased driver and pedestrian safety; endangerment of school children: decreased air quality; parking lot crime; environmental and aesthetic degradation, all of which decrease the enjoyment and marketability of the neighborhoods close to the site. Read on for more information or act now >>


Wal-Mart stores are short-lived.

Due to nationwide retail glut, the lifespan of a Wal-Mart store is shockingly short. Wal-Mart has a history of abandoning its stores, and, in fact, is the industry leader in the 'empty box syndrome.' In March of 2005, there were 356 'available' Wal-Marts on the market, located in 41 states. Thirty-one percent of these stores are larger than 100,000 sq ft. Thirty-one percent of these stores have been on the market for longer than three years. To add insult to injury, Wal-Mart has a habit of reneging on its lease obligations while holding onto abandoned properties to prevent competitors from moving in, leaving the community with angry developers or long-lasting big box eyesores. (38) Wal-Mart is a short-lived discount boondoggle that will impart long-lasting and perhaps irreparable fiscal, economic and environmental harm to Oregon.


Footnotes:

1. "The Impact of Big Box Grocers on Southern California: Jobs, Wages and Municipal Finances," Prepared for the Orange County Business Council by Dr. Marlon Boarnet of the University of California at Irvine and Dr. Randall Crane of the University of California at Los Angeles, 1999. Available online at www.coalitiontlc.org/big_box_study.pdf
2. "Impact of the Wal-Mart Phenomenon on Rural Communities," Kenneth E. Stone, Professor of Economics, Iowa State University, 1997. Available online at http://www.seta.iastate.edu/retail/publications/10_yr_study.pdf
3. Letters to the Editor. The Nation. 2/28/05. "Wal-Mart: We Empty Our Trash," and "Featherstone Replies." Sarah Clark, Wal-Mart Spokesperson, and Liza Featherstone in response to Featherstone's 1/3/05 story, "Down and Out in Discount America." Available online at www.TheNation.com See archive.
4. "Wal-Mart Memo Suggests Ways to Cut Employee Benefit Costs," Steven Greenhouse and Michael Barbaro, New York Times, 10/26/05. Available online at http://www.nytimes.com. See search.
5. "Everyday Low Wages: The Hidden Price We All Pay for Wal-Mart," A Report by the Democratic Staff of the Committee on Education and Workforce, U.S. House of Representatives, February 16, 2004. Available online at http://edworkforce.house.gov/democ rats/WALMARTREPORT.pdf
6. "Wal-Mart: An Example of Why Workers Remain Uninsured and Underinsured," October 2003, AFL-CIO. Available online at www.aflcio.org/ issuespolitics/healthpolicy/upload/Wal-Mart_final.pdf
7. Details of Wal-Mart health plans examined in this article. "Wal-Mart offers sham health care as publicity stunt. New Name, Same Basic Plan - Extremely High Deductibles & Strict Eligibility Requirements." Available online at http://wakeupwalmart.com/press/2005102 4-release.html
8. "Hidden Cost of Wal-Mart Jobs." UC Berkeley's Institute for Industrial Relations, August 2004. Available online at 9. "What Do We Know About Wal-Mart? An Overview of Facts and Studies for New Yorkers." Annette Bernhardt et al. Brennan Center for Justice. NYU School of Law. Economic Policy Brief No 2. August 2005. Available online at http://www.brennancenter.o rg/programs/downloads/aboutwalmart.pdf See also "Major Users of State Provided Health Insurance Programs" Available online at http://www.wakeupwalmart.com/facts/st ate-reports.html
10. "Wal-Mart's Benefits Come Under Fire," Contra Costa Times, Oct 2003, Available online at http://www.contracostatime s.com/mld/cctimes/business/7051008.htm
11. "Wal-Mart and County-Wide Poverty," Stephan Goetz and Hema Swaminathan, Penn State University, October 2004. Available online at http://www.newrules.org/retail/econimpact.ht ml
12. "Impact of the Wal-Mart Phenomenon on Rural Communities," Kenneth E. Stone, Professor of Economics, Iowa State University, 1997. Available online at http://www.seta.iastate.edu /retail/publications/10_yr_study.pdf
13 "Is Wal-Mart Too Powerful?" Business Week, Oct 6, 2003. Available online at http://www.businesswe ek.com/magazine/content/03_40/b3852001_mz001.htm
14. "What Happened When Wal-Mart Came to Town? A Report on Three Iowa Communities with a Statistical Analysis of Seven Iowa Counties," Thomas Muller and Elizabeth Humstone, National Trust For Historic Preservation, 1996. Summary available online at http://www.newrules.org/retail/econimpact.ht ml
15. The Case Against Wal-Mart, Al Norman. Raphael Marketing, 2004. Chapter 5: Unfair Competition, pp 43 – 68. 16. St. Albans, Vermont State Environmental Board Act 250 Decision, 1994, Summary available online at http://www.newrules.org/retail/econimpact.ht ml
17. "Fiscal & Economic Impact Assessment of the Proposed Wal-Mart Development," Land Use Inc. and RKG Associates, 1993. Summary available online at http://www.newrules.org/retail/econimpact.ht ml
18. "The Fiscal and Economic Impact of a proposed Shopping Center Project on the City of Leomister. Thomas Muller, August 2003. Available online at 19. The Case Against Wal-Mart. Al Norman. Raphael Marketing, 2004. Multiple cases of predatory pricing, including lawsuits against the retail giant, are documented on pp 55-65. 21. "Fiscal Impact Analysis of Residential and Nonresidential Land Use Prototypes," Tischler & Associates, July 2002. Available online at http://amiba.net/pdf/barnstable_fiscal_i mpact_report.pdf
22. "Understanding the Fiscal Impacts of Land Use in Ohio," Randall Gross, Development EconomicsAugust 2004. Available online at http:/ /www.regionalconnections.org/resources/documents/pdf/reports/fiscalimpacts.pdf
23. "Impacts of Development on DuPage County Property Taxes," prepared by DuPage County Development Department for the County Regional Planning Commission, Illinois, October 1991. Summary available online at http://www.newrules.org/retail/econimpact.ht ml
24. "Understanding the Tax Base Consequences of Local Economic Development," RKG Associates, 2001. Available online at http://www.rkg1.com/pdfs/taxbasemgmt.pdf
25. "Impacts of Development on DuPage County Property Taxes," prepared by DuPage County Development Department for the County Regional Planning Commission, Illinois, October 1991. Summary available online at http://www.newrules.org/retail/econimpact.ht ml
26. "The Economic Impact of Locally Owned Businesses vs. Chains: A Case Study in Midcoast Maine ,"Institute for Local Self-Reliance and Friends of Midcoast Maine, September 2003. Available online at http://www.newrules.org/retail/midcoaststu dy.pdf
27. "The Andersonville Study of Retail Economics," Civic Economics, 2004. Available online at http://www.civiceconomics.com/Andersonville
28. "Retail Sprawl Impairing Nation's Waterways," The Hometown Advantage: Reviving Locally Owned Business, September 1, 2003. Available online at http://www.newrules.org/retail/news_archive.php?browseby=slug&slugid=236
29. "Retail Sprawl Impairing Nation's Waterways," The Hometown Advantage: Reviving Locally Owned Business, September 1, 2003. Available online at http://www.newrules.org/retail/news_archive.php?browseby=slug&slugid=236
30. "The Importance of Imperviousness," Watershed ProtectionTechniques 1(3) 100-111 Available online at http://www.cwp.org/Practice/1.pdf
31. "The Importance of Imperviousness," Watershed ProtectionTechniques 1(3) 100-111 Available online at http://www.cwp.org/Practice/1.pdf
32. "Cars Are Leading Source of Metal Loads in California," Tech Note #13 from Watershed ProtectionTechniques 1(1):28. Available online at http://www.cwp.org/Practice/6.pdf
33. "EPA Hits Wal-Mart With Big Fine for Clean Water Act Violations—Again," May 5, 2004. Available online at http://www.sprawl-busters.com/searc h.php?readstory=1431 See also, "US Announces Major Clean Water Act Settlement with Retail Giant Wal-Mart," USDOJ Press Release, May 12, 2004. Available online at http://www.usdoj .gov/usao/de/press/2004pressreleases/walmart_complaint.pdf See also, "US Reaches Water Pollution Settlement with Wal-Mart," USEPA Press Release, June 7, 2001. Available online at http://www.mindfully.org/Water/Wal-Mart -Pay-$1M.htm
34. "Retail Sprawl Impairing Nation's Waterways," The Hometown Advantage: Reviving Locally Owned Business, September 1, 2003. Available online at http://www.newrules.org/retail/news_archive.php?browseby=slug&slugid=236
35. "Wal-Mart's Impact on Local Police Costs." A summary of recent newspaper articles from around the country reporting on this problem. The Hometown Advantage: Reviving Locally-Owned Business. Available online at http://www.newrules.org/retail/policefac tsheet.pdf
36. "Is Wal-Mart Too Powerful?" Business Week, 10/6/03. Available online at http://www.businesswe ek.com/magazine/content/03_40/b3852001_mz001.htm
37. "Seams Start to Unravel," LA Times, part of the 2003 series, "The Wal-Mart Effect," 11/24/03. Available online at http://www. latimes.com/news/custom/showcase/la-fi-reed24nov2403,0,5725975.story
38. "Wal-Mart has 356 Dark Stores Available for Sale or Lease," Bentonville, Arkansas, March 5, 2005. Available online at http://www.sprawl-busters.com/searc h.php?readstory=1757

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

Deixe aqui sua opinião!

<< Home